Since no one tried to make a list in a while I'll give this a shot. This is my first attempt at this.
1 Hades Elite -SINK. any alliance with elite in the name will sink
2 Ghost Riders -SINK. pact with Hades elite SPQR and LEAGUE OF SHADOWS the leader looks to have little experience
3 Veni Vidi Vici -FLOAT. Has high average point value Leader marine warpig looks relatively inexperienced best award is top 100 in an ocean, mostly dispersed cities over 2 oceans, one tight cluster
4 Trojan Tribute - FLOAT. Has high average point value and tight city clustering on the map , They havent moved in position for a while. It would be nice to know more about them
5 Illyrians Hegemony - SINK eventually. Remake of the alliance on Sigma mostly dispersed cities over 2 oceans one tight cluster, too close to the core for their own good. they will melt under competition
6 Lycans - SWIM for now. some good players from other worlds in here. half an ocean away from the worlds center lower competition out there, relitively good clustering, not so impressed by the experience of most of their leadership
7 What does the Fox Say?- SWIM. good leadership in charl and tight clustering of cities
8 Resurrected- SINK eventually. lower end average points areas of tight clustering with lots of outliers. half an ocean away from the worlds center, if they would kick the lower players out this alliance would be good candidate to have merge into another alliance
9 The Laestrygonians - SWIM, if they recruit more higher point members. I like the experience of the leadership esp BLT the conqueror 148 cities, very tight grouping a little weak on average points
10 55-22 -SINK. tight grouping but too close to the center of the world. Unsatisfied with the roster of players, a few people from the alliance warlords from sigma here. Unsatisfied with their alliance profile.
11 GaMe oVeR - FLOAT for now. high point value, spread over a large area an ocean, Hard to defend later on. leader looks to have no playing experience from grepostats but somehow I feel that mantaras had played before
12 LEAGUE OF SHADOWS -SINK nice clustering but a possible repeat of sigma for this alliance