You graded myself kind of weird....for example I am 5th in ABP and 25th in points, but an extra point in points?
Regardless, your grade:
Alliance-6/10 (lack of support to members, limiting targets to one alliance w/o approval, sharing ocean with another alliance, lack of overall cohesion in the alliance, a strong offensive force with high ABP members)
Points-8/10 (you are 18th in points so very high up, but you have an average below 5k so I subtracted for that and the kind of low placement, though 18th is still pretty high up)
ABP-9/10 (aside from being up top and a 10/10, I think that is a just score)