I like entry 4 the best. The fox
Anyway, since I do not know who did what, I sure hope no one takes my reasoning of my vote too personal.
I voted for #2 as it simply IMO showed the most graphical talent to create. And since this is about graphics, it won my vote.
Entry #3 though personally looked equally dope and visually appealing (if not better), yes, But this was just due to picking a good photo that went with the darkness, clouds, and lightning. And them lightning plug ins are played to me.. so.. yea. (just IMO) - But that soccer ball watermark thing is NICE DUDE !!!
Entry #1 imo was, eh.. don't really see the "umph" there. Constructive criticism is I can pick apart how it was created too easily, so the "magic" of how it is showing me what it is showing is simply not there.
Side note - Funny when the subject is sports... there isn't one white person in peoples graphic examples. Haha !