Border: 7 (10) I can't say I like it... but it fits with the color theme.
Text: 6 (10) If I didn't know the theme for this week I would have thought it said "I Love Pood".
Lighting: 0 (15) No lighting attempted. I cannot exempt this from final grade.
Color: 15 (15) Color generally is coherent.
Design: 17 (35) No use of ROT. Focus of piece is not clear.
Detail: 1 (5) None that I can see... maybe I am missing something here?
Creativity: 2 (10) It is a burger plopped on a MacDonald's M on a colored background. I mean, I guess it fits the theme.
+6 for effort because like phil said it was a hard week.
Border: 3 (10) Too thick, and white borders really defeat the purpose of the border (to enclose).
Text: 8 (10) Simple, but fits the general idea of your piece.
Lighting: 0 (15) Again, not attempted.
Color: 12 (15) I think you were going more for humor than beauty here. Colors don't match, but it doesn't take away from the piece too much.
Design: 28 (35) Fits ROT.
Detail: 1 (5) Not really attempted.
Creativity: 7.5 (10) Funny.
Border: 9 (10) Unconventional. But I like it.
Text: 7.5 (10) Good graphically, not sure what it is supposed to mean.
Lighting: 0 (15) Jeez, not attempted again. COME ON GRAPHIC GURUS! STEP IT UP!
Color: 15 (15) Great coherence.
Design: 35 (35) Fits ROT (both render AND text!!!)
Detail: 5 (5) Very nice!!!
Creativity: 8 (10) A talking pear. What's not to love? For me, 2 points is what.
I feel like I am being too harsh. Please let me know.