Lol we should make a list of the twelve worst players in Grepolis. That would be a fun trash talk forum.
Serious question. What criteria must be met for you to consider a player up to your standards? Not just good, but top 5.
the top 12 players are the top 12 players in BP right now LOL... no questions asked
good question, I would point out it is "players" and not "fighters" so you would have to consider other skills outside just individual battle tactics. Personally I think developmental skills are huge, developing solid players from the raw jello that spawns into their first world is a major asset. Training the rookie players of an alliance is a rare quality and is very different from recruiting a ton of experienced talent to your premade. That could fall under the umbrella of leadership skills though along with diplomacy, larger alliance tactics, ability to motivate, etc.